Antique Stores in Sayville, New York

Discover 3 antique stores, vintage shops, and collectible dealers in Sayville, New York. Find unique treasures with store details, hours, and an interactive map.

Map of Antique Stores in Sayville

All 3 Antique Stores in Sayville

Browse all antique stores, vintage shops, and collectible dealers in Sayville, New York.

Paper Doll Vintage Boutique

2 Main St, Sayville, NY 11782

+1 631-319-1919

Paper Doll Vintage Boutique in Sayville, New York, offers a charming selection of vintage clothing and accessories. Shoppers can find unique pieces ranging from retro apparel to antique jewelry and collectibles. The boutique is known for its friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere, making it a delightful place to explore and discover one-of-a-kind treasures.

Sayville Antiques

136 A Main St, Sayville, NY 11782

+1 631-589-4653

Sayville Antiques in Sayville, New York, offers a diverse selection of vintage and antique items. Shoppers can find unique furniture pieces, rare coins, and collectible toys among other treasures. The store is known for its friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere, making it a delightful place to explore and discover hidden gems.

The Long Island Peddler Toys and Antiques

186 W Main St unit 11, Sayville, NY 11782

+1 631-902-0207

The Long Island Peddler Toys and Antiques in Sayville, New York, offers a charming selection of vintage toys, rare coins, and unique collectibles. Visitors can explore an array of antique ceramics, retro items, and nostalgic memorabilia. The store provides a welcoming atmosphere where customers can enjoy browsing and discovering hidden treasures.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

From the Blog

Learn more about antique shopping in Sayville, New York with our expert guides and articles.

Shopping Tips18 min read

Antique Stores on Long Island, New York: Your Complete Guide to Finding Vintage Treasures

Discover the best antique stores on Long Island, New York. From Long Island City warehouses to North Fork barn shops, explore Long Island's diverse vintage scene.

Antique Store Locator Team·February 27, 2026

View all blog posts →

About Antique Shopping in Sayville, New York

Sayville, New York is home to 3 antique stores offering a diverse selection of vintage furniture, collectibles, estate jewelry, and unique decorative items. Whether you are a seasoned collector or just discovering the world of antiques, Sayville has something for everyone.

Use our interactive map above to plan your antique shopping route, or browse the store listings for addresses, phone numbers, and business hours.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many antique stores are in Sayville, New York?

There are 3 antique stores in Sayville, New York. Our directory includes addresses, phone numbers, business hours, and maps for each store.

Where are antique stores located in Sayville?

Antique stores in Sayville are spread across the city. Use our interactive map above to see exact locations and plan your visit.

What types of antiques can I find in Sayville?

Antique stores in Sayville, New York offer vintage furniture, collectibles, estate jewelry, art, decorative items, and more. Each store has its own specialties.

Do antique stores in Sayville offer appraisals?

Many antique stores in Sayville offer appraisal services. Contact individual stores directly for details about appraisals, consignment, and other services.

Are there antique stores near Sayville?

Yes! In addition to the 3 stores in Sayville, there are many antique stores in nearby cities throughout New York. Browse our state directory to find more options.

More Cities with Antique Stores in New York

New York(188)Brooklyn(43)Hudson(25)Buffalo(19)Rochester(16)Kingston(13)Flushing(12)Syracuse(11)Locust Valley(10)Cold Spring(10)Binghamton(10)Long Island City(9)

Browse Antique Stores in Other States

Texas(1465)California(1253)Pennsylvania(926)Florida(820)North Carolina(713)Illinois(705)Ohio(646)Georgia(637)